TechFlorida sued over ban on lab-grown meat by Upside Foods

Florida sued over ban on lab‑grown meat by Upside Foods

Upside Foods has filed a lawsuit against the state of Florida, claiming that the ban on the sale of lab-grown meat is unconstitutional. The law aims to protect people from being forced to eat insects and artificial meat.

Natural meat or artificial?
Natural meat or artificial?
Images source: © Adobe Stock | CELIO MESSIAS

Upside Foods, specializing in the production of lab-grown meat, argues that the state's ban on such products is unconstitutional. The ban, signed by Governor Ron DeSantis in May, is portrayed as a measure to "fighting back against the global elite’s plan to force the world to eat meat grown in a petri dish or bugs to achieve their authoritarian goals." It has been criticized as an attempt to protect the local livestock industry.

According to The Verge, Upside Foods, supported by the Institute for Justice, a non-profit organization, argues that this law violates both constitutional clauses regarding supremacy and interstate commerce, as well as federal meat product regulations.

Florida Commissioner of Agriculture Wilton Simpson called the lawsuit "ridiculous," highlighting the deep divisions regarding artificial meat.

Upside Foods emphasizes that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) deemed their products safe in 2022, and the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) approved the sale of their products and those of the competing company Good Meat a year later. The company argues that the Florida ban not only hinders its operations within the state but also complicates cooperation with national meat distributors and limits expansion opportunities due to similar laws inspired by it in other states.

The court will clarify the matter

In its lawsuit, Upside Foods appeals for the ban to be declared unconstitutional and seeks temporary and permanent remedies to prevent its enforcement.

The situation has complicated the company's plans, including participating in the Art Basel fair in Miami before the controversial law took effect. At a press conference, Paul Sherman, a lawyer from the Institute for Justice representing Upside Foods, expressed hope for a quick resolution. He emphasized that consumers should decide whether to consume lab-grown meat rather than being restricted by legal mandates.

According to Sherman, states should not block access to products approved at the federal level, highlighting the role of consumer choice in shaping the market.

The topic of artificial meat stirs controversy among consumers. Considering the development of this industry, attention should also be paid to the overall cost-effectiveness of the production process in terms of energy consumption and potential environmental pollution compared to naturally sourced meat.

Related content

© essanews.com
·

Downloading, reproduction, storage, or any other use of content available on this website—regardless of its nature and form of expression (in particular, but not limited to verbal, verbal-musical, musical, audiovisual, audio, textual, graphic, and the data and information contained therein, databases and the data contained therein) and its form (e.g., literary, journalistic, scientific, cartographic, computer programs, visual arts, photographic)—requires prior and explicit consent from Wirtualna Polska Media Spółka Akcyjna, headquartered in Warsaw, the owner of this website, regardless of the method of exploration and the technique used (manual or automated, including the use of machine learning or artificial intelligence programs). The above restriction does not apply solely to facilitate their search by internet search engines and uses within contractual relations or permitted use as specified by applicable law.Detailed information regarding this notice can be found  here.

We value your privacy

essanews.com is a part of Wirtualna Polska media company. Click "I ACCEPT AND GO TO THE WEBSITE" to give your consent to the use of automated technologies to collect and use data on the Internet, and to the processing of your personal data by Wirtualna Polska, IAB Trusted Partners (869 partners) and other Trusted Partners (403 partners), and to our sharing with the aforementioned Trusted Partners of the identifiers assigned to you for marketing purposes (including for automated matching of advertisements to your interests and for measuring their effectiveness) and for other purposes that we specify below. You can also make decisions about permissions in the Advanced settings.


Based on your consent, Wirtualna Polska, IAB Trusted Partners and other Trusted Partners will process your personal data collected on the Internet (including on e-commerce partners' websites), including through forms, such as IP addresses, your device identifiers and cookie identifiers, and other identifiers assigned to you and information about your activity on the Internet. The data will be processed for the following purpose: to store or access information on a device, use limited data to select advertising, create profiles for personalized advertising, use profiles to select personalized advertising, create profiles related to personalize content, use profiles to select personalized content, measure advertising performance, measure content performance, understand audiences through statistics or combinations of data from different sources, develop and improve services, use limited data to select content.


Within the framework of its functions and special functions, Wirtualna Polska may take the following actions:

  1. Match and combine data from other data sources
  2. Link different devices
  3. Identify devices based on information transmitted automatically
  4. Actively scan device characteristics for identification

The purposes of processing of your data by IAB Trusted Partners and other Trusted Partners are as follows:

  1. Store and/or access information on a device
  2. Use limited data to select advertising
  3. Create profiles for personalised advertising
  4. Use profiles to select personalised advertising
  5. Create profiles to personalise content
  6. Use profiles to select personalised content
  7. Measure advertising performance
  8. Measure content performance
  9. Understand audiences through statistics or combinations of data from different sources
  10. Develop and improve services
  11. Use limited data to select content
  12. Ensure security, prevent and detect fraud, and fix errors
  13. Deliver and present advertising and content
  14. Save and communicate privacy choices

Within the framework of the functions and special functions, our IAB Trusted Partners and Trusted Partners may take the following actions:

  1. Match and combine data from other data sources
  2. Link different devices
  3. Identify devices based on information transmitted automatically
  4. Actively scan device characteristics for identification

In order to take the above action, our IAB Trusted Partners and other Trusted Partners also need your consent, which you can give by clicking "I ACCEPT AND GO TO THE WEBSITE" or make a decision regarding the consent in Advanced settings.


The purposes of processing your data without a need to obtain your consent based on the legitimate interest of Wirtualna Polska and IAB Trusted Partners are stated, and the option to object to the processing, is available in Advanced settings.


The purposes, special purposes, features and special features of the data processing are described in detail in the Advanced Settings.


Here you can find the websites of our e-commerce partners, from which we may process your personal data on the basis of your consent.


The consent is voluntary and you can withdraw it at any time after reopening the settings window by clicking on the "Privacy Settings" link located in the footer of each website.


Please note that by giving your consent, your data may be transferred to our Trusted Partners in third countries, i.e. countries outside the European Economic Area.


You have the right to request access, rectification, deletion, restriction, transfer of data processing, file an objection, file a complaint with the regulatory authority under the terms of the Privacy Policy.


To change your privacy preferences, you can click on the Advanced Settings or "Privacy Settings" link located in the footer of each website where you can provide or withdraw consent or otherwise manage your choices. Detailed information about the processing of your personal data can be found in the privacy policy.