HealthButter vs. margarine: Expert reveals the healthier choice

Butter vs. margarine: Expert reveals the healthier choice

Margarine contains harmful trans fats. Butter is a better alternative.
Margarine contains harmful trans fats. Butter is a better alternative.
Images source: © Adobe Stock

3:39 PM EDT, October 7, 2024

Many people can't imagine a sandwich without a spread—we commonly use butter or margarine. But is that the right choice? Does margarine have fewer calories than butter? Which of these products is more beneficial? We'll try to explain.

The debate about the health benefits of butter and margarine has been ongoing for a long time. This is no surprise, as they are very popular bread spreads. Butter consists of at least 80% animal fat and dairy and provides vitamins such as A, which supports vision; e, which is known for its antioxidant properties; and D, which strengthens bones and teeth. Margarines are divided into soft ones, used as a butter substitute, and hard ones, used for frying or baking.

Butter and margarine - what to choose for daily consumption?

Butter contains saturated fats, while margarine contains "artificial" trans fats. This is a very important difference. Both saturated and trans fats negatively affect LDL cholesterol levels while simultaneously lowering HDL levels. However, trans fats are more harmful to health than saturated ones.

Even though butter contains saturated fats, it also has short and medium-chain fatty acids. Thanks to this, the fats are not as detrimental to our body. It has been proven that butter is the healthiest and easiest to digest among all fats known to us.

And what about caloric content? In this case, the matter is not entirely clear. Margarine indeed has fewer calories, but due to the presence of trans fats, it is not a recommended substitute for butter. Trans fats are responsible for the development of dangerous diseases, including heart disease, depression, and cancers, and they also increase the risk of infertility.

The expert strongly advises against consuming margarine, regardless of age, emphasizing that they still do not constitute a healthy, natural choice even with adding vitamins or herbs to margarine. From a health perspective, butter is the better choice.

However, many people decide to forgo both butter and margarine completely. Increasingly interesting alternatives for spreading on bread include nut creams, avocado spreads, or hummus.