Alabama Supreme Court Decision could redefine IVF Embryo Legal Status

Alabama Supreme Court Decision could redefine IVF Embryo Legal Status
Images source: © GETTY | The Washington Post

11:32 AM EST, February 21, 2024

In an unprecedented ruling, the Alabama Supreme Court classified frozen embryos as "children," greenlighting two wrongful death lawsuits against a fertility clinic in Mobile. This landmark decision could profoundly affect those pursuing IVF or other reproductive aids, potentially leading to heightened legal scrutiny for expectant individuals seeking these treatments.

Alabama's medical community is grappling with uncertainty around the future of in vitro fertilization treatments following a state Supreme Court decision that frozen embryos are considered people. The ruling has sent shockwaves through couples, who are now flocking to online support groups, deliberating whether to move their frozen embryos out of state to avoid potential legal complications. Legal experts are also raising alarms that divorce agreements mandating the destruction of frozen embryos could be invalidated. The verdict has triggered a mix of shock, anger, and bewilderment across Alabama, putting women's reproductive health care at a crossroads in a state known for its stringent abortion restrictions.

In Alabama, the law has unique aspects that might limit the reach of a recent decision. Specifically, the Wrongful Death of a Minor Act allows for civil lawsuits only under certain conditions, and the state's criminal homicide law applies to unborn children within the womb, making it unclear if harm to an embryo in a cryogenic facility could lead to criminal charges. However, recent rulings by Alabama's Supreme Court, which is entirely Republican, suggest an expansion of the state's control over embryonic life, raising concerns for those seeking IVF treatments about potential restrictions on such care.

Sources: VOX; TheGuardian; WashingtonPost

Related content